Theater and Live Performance

TV Reviews
Classic Films
Performance and Theater
Opera Reviews
20th Century Opera
Macabre Books
Hollywood Poop
Kate Hepburn
The Sundance Kid
Fantastic 4
TV: Alias
Quirk's Hollywood Stars Photo Page
Superhero Comic Review
set for Il tabarro from 2007 Met production
set design by Douglas W. Schmidt

On this page we will post occasional reviews of interesting and unusual live theater, opera, and music performances.

Lauren Flanagan as Vanessa

VANESSA. Samuel Barber. Libretto by Gian Carlo Menotti. New York City Opera. November 2007. Wealthy Vanessa once had a passionate affair with a man named Anatol, but when it ended, she retreated to her huge home, covered all the mirrors and paintings of herself, and foolishly waited twenty years for Anatol to return to her. When he finally arrives, he turns out not to be Anatol at all, but his son and namesake, who promptly hits on Vanessa’s niece Erika and knocks her up. Erika is not blind to shifty freeloader Anatol’s flaws but Vanessa gradually accepts him and falls thoroughly in love with the wastrel. As the couple leave for Paris to live in improbable bliss, Erika decides it is her turn to wait for the man of her dreams (?) to return to her and orders the mirrors and paintings again covered over. Okay, the story of Vanessa shouldn’t be taken too literally – it certainly examines how people can become obsessed with someone, such as Anatol, who is utterly unworthy of their interest – but Barber and Menotti would certainly have been pleased with this wonderful production at NYCO. First of all, congratulations are in order for set designer Michael Yeargan who avoided the trendy avant garde approach and came up with an attractive, functional set that didn’t noisily or stupidly compete with the music and singers. Said music was well-conducted by Anne Manson, and the singers were all in good form. The story of Vanessa is a little dopey, and the characters are paper-thin, but there are lovely moments in the score, which include notable arias for both Vanessa and her niece Erika in act one, a couple of fine duets in later acts, and a melodious closing quintet to send the audience home happy. Lauren Flanagan was Vanessa, with Katharine Goeldner as Erika, Ryan MacPherson as Anatol, Rosalind Elias as Vanessa’s mother, Richard Stilwell as the doctor, and Branch Fields as the Major-Domo; all were in top form. Vanessa may not be one of the world’s greatest operas by any means, but taken on its own terms, as this production made clear, it is not without its charms and a basically romantic lyricism of its own.

tenor Salvatore Licitra

IL TRITTICO. Puccini. Metropolitan Opera. May 1st, 2007. This was a superb presentation of Puccini's evening of three one-act operas, beginning with Il tabarro (the cloak), followed by Suor Angelica, and finishing with Gianni Schicchi. Director Jack O'Brien's production, with set designs by Douglas W. Schmidt, was a stunner -- the sets complemented the music and action instead of distracting us from them -- and more to the point there were some wonderful singers in evidence. As James Levine was ill, he was replaced at the podium by Joseph Colaneri who conducted with vigor. Il tabarro takes place on a boat in what appeared to be a tributary of the main river, with a factory across the narrow channel and a bridge spanning the stage from left to right high overhead. Salvatore Licitra, a dramatic tenor, made a strong impression in the role of young lover Luigi. Juan Pons' voice is not quite what it used to be, but he was still rather effective as Michele, who is married to Giorgetta. It may have been an off night for Maria Guleghina, who sang the role, or verismo may not be her forte, but her voice was all over the lot, unpleasant and haggard. Judging from this performance she might have to stick to Mama Lucia from Cavalleria from now on. Much better than Guleghina was Stephanie Blyth, who appeared in all three operas, singing the role of Frugola in the first installment.

Barbara Frittoli -- an artist of the first rank

Archways in a sparse garden dominated the set for Suor Angelica, which takes place in a convent. Blythe again made her mark as the princess, but there were plenty of bravas for Barbara Frittoli in the title role. Possessed of an enviably beautiful voice, Frittoli is an artiste of the first rank; her work was thrilling. Barbara Dever was also fine as the Mistress of Novices. Stephanie Blythe sang Zita in Gianni Schicchi, which featured a bedroom set framed like a painting. During the final scene an elevator descends to reveal a balcony overlooking gardens and a pool. An excellent Alessandro Corbelli displayed a beautiful tone in the title role; tenor Massimo Giordano made a vocally imperfect but nonetheless notable Rinuccio, shyly wiping away the lipstick on his mouth after a kiss from his girlfriend. As Lauretta, said girlfriend and the daughter of Schicchi, Olga Mykytenko gave a sweet rendition of the famous aria “O mio babbino caro.”

All in all, a truly great evening at the Met.

Karita Mattila

JENUFA. Janacek. Metropolitan Opera. This production of Janacek's opera is excellent on virtually every level. Jiri Belohlavek conducts this clearly verismo score with vigor and enthusiasm. Karita Mattila scores in the title role but all of the singers give superior performances. While the score doesn't consist of one “hit” number after another, it is still quite lyrical, melodious, and well-orchestrated by Janacek. Janacek handles all of the highly dramatic situations in the opera with aplomb. The production design by Frank Phillip Schlössmann is attractive and striking without being so oddball that it distracts from the music and singing; Schlössmann also did the costumes. Lighting design by Max Keller and entire production supervised by Olivier Tambosi. This one is a real winner for the Met.


LA FARSA AMOROSA. Teatro Grattacielo. Alice Tully Hall, Lincoln Center. November 11th, 2006. The Teatro Grattacielo company revives another lost opera from the [post-]verismo period with this concert production of Riccardo Zandonai's final complete opera La Farsa Amorosa/The Amorous Farce (1933). Zandonai's best-known opera was Francesca da Rimini (1914), which had a notable production at the Met with Placido Domingo.The opera:The story concerns the mayor, Don Ferrante, of a small town, who is a philander and has set his cap on Lucia, the wife of the farmer Renzo. Don Ferrante arranges for Renzo to be arrested so he can pay a call on Lucia. When Renzo mistakenly believes that the mayor has slept with his wife, he decides to dress up in the former's clothes and pay a call on the mayor's beautiful spouse Mercedes. But it all ends happily, with Renzo and Lucia reunited and the repentant mayor's love for his wife rekindled. Zamdonai responds to A. Rossato's libretto with lovely music that is very well orchestrated and which skillfully illuminates the emotions of the characters. The beautiful overture is both whimsical and dramatic. Although the mayor is a pompous jackass – a donkey brays each time he appears to underline this – the music as he sings of his ardor for Lucia evokes a certain sympathy for his torment. Act one features a memorable Chorus of Grape Harvesters and a rhapsodic duet between Lucia and Renzo that one wishes had gone on much longer. The Mayor is given a very nice piece in act two [“Quante dame, quante spose”] in which he sings of his romantic adventures and how he can forget them all when he thinks of Lucia. The great Pietro Mascagni was Zandonai's teacher and his influence is especially obvious in Renzo's piece “La Podestessa e bella.”in which the farmer decides to go sleep with the mayor's wife. Act two ends with a notable quartet [with chorus] O Mio Renzo! Mercedes is then given a pretty song at the opening of act three [“Stanotte apparecchio]. Lucia's aria “Puoi dunque credere,” in which she agonizes over the fact that her husband thought she was unfaithful is a bit disappointing, but it leads into a glorious arioso for Renzo [“Ah! Se potessi stringerla,”] in which he reacts to her heartbreak with his own despair. The opera ends with a beautiful chorus as all the issues are resolved and husband and wife are reconciled. While La Farsa Amorosa doesn't have the consistent melodiousness of say, Mascagni's L'amico Fritz, it is a worthwhile, amusing, and frequently lyrical opera. The production: Teatro Grattaciello has come up with another winning evening. Maestro David Wroe [Mark Shapiro is the associate conductor] conducts the Teatro Grattacielo orchestra with verve and sensitivity to the various moods and flavorings of the score. Tenor Todd Geer, in the role of Renzo, has a voice that is both sweet and powerful, a rare combination, and he makes love to every note. Pretty soprano Monica Yunus makes a splendid Lucia, while the equally attractive Anna Tonna is very expressive as Donna Mercedes. Baritone Peter Castaldi with his rich tone is a highly effective Don Ferrante. There were also fine singing performances from Steven Goldstein (Frulla), Eric D. Johnson (Springarda), Tracy Rhodus (Orsola) and John Tiranno (Giacomino). The Cantori New York Chorus, whose artistic director is Mark Shapiro, was in excellent form during the several chorale pieces. The performance was dedicated to the late Maestro Alfredo Silipigni, and the composer's daughter, Jolanda Tarquinia Zandonai, was the guest of honor. All in all, a memorable night at the concert hall. William Schoell [author of Opera of the Twentieth Century]

Soprano Olga Borodina

LA GIOCONDA. Metropolitan Opera. October 4th, 2006. This was a workmanlike if somewhat uninspired production of Ponchielli's great romantic melodrama. Although the story, from Victor Hugo, has its fascinating aspects, the libretto is rather clumsy, but who really cares when its Ponchielli's great, soaring melodies that make this matter. Sopranos Olga Borodina and Violeta Urmana make a solid Laura and La Gioconda, respectively, but mezzo Irina Mishura really scores as La Cieca, the blind mother of the heroine. Aquiles Machado is an acceptable Enzo, a good singer without an especially attractive voice [at least at this performance]. but baritone Zeljko Lucic exhibits a strong and wonderful sound throughout. One incident illustrates the fact that too many opera newcomers – while their presence is welcome – don't understand exactly how to behave when it comes to showing their appreciation of the singers. For instance, Machado did a fairly strong rendition of “Cielo del mar” but choked on the final note – yet he got bravos from some members of the audience. Polite applause, certainly no rude boos – but bravos? For choking? This was definitely the case of people applauding a great aria and not the singer. Newcomers to the opera should remember that they should become a little more seasoned before they applaud, hiss or yell “Bravo!” When in doubt, wait and see what the rest of the audience does. Whatever its flaws, La gioconda deserves its place in the repertoire. Ironically, the people who got the biggest applause of the evening weren't any of the singers but rather the aattractive young dancers featured in the ballet sequence [One can only imagine the curses coming from the backstage dressing rooms afterward.] Although opera fans and ballet fans occasionally overlap, generally this is not the case. It is likely that the operagoers at this performance overpraised the ballet, which was pretty and nice but probably not that spectacular to the initiated.


DIE TOTE STADT. Erich Wolfgang Korngold. New York City Opera. September 27th, 2006. This was an excellent production of Korngold's deeply moving and intensely romantic masterpiece. Employing film strips, slides and screens that seamlessly blend with the actors and props on stage, this Frank Corsaro staging of the opera [the films were made by Paul Chase on location in Bruges] creates a dream-like effect that adds to its mesmerizing and sensuous [not to mention sensual] quality. The story deals with a bereaved husband who meets a woman who reminds him of his late wife and emerges as a cautionary tale of keeping ties too strongly with the past and of pursuing an illusion. It is one of the greatest studies of grief and loneliness ever crafted. Although saddled with a cold, soprano Susan B. Anthony [sic!] sounded pretty good as Marie and Marietta. Dan Charmandy may not emerge as one of my favorite tenors, but his voice is powerful enough to handle the difficult role of Paul. Baritone Keith Phares as Frtiz made a favorable impression on the audience with his rendition of “Pierrot's Lament.”The score was generally conducted with panache by George Manahan. Although the movie strip and slide show approach may not work for most operas, it is a perfect fit with Die Tote Stadt. And the music ... Although the act one duet is always singled out as a sublime moment in the score, the opera is actually filled with great music including two other beautiful duets. Wunderbar! -- William Schoell.

Ramos (left) and Smith in "Lens"
click on photo to order tickets

THROUGH A NAKED LENS. Written by George Barthel. Directed by Richard Bacon and L. J. Kleeman. At the Wings Theater. Note: Click on the photo on the left to go directly to the Wings website, where you can read more about the play and cast members, as well as order tickets online. Through a Naked Lens is an exceptional play about the love affair between silent star Ramon Navarro and Photoplay writer Herbert Howe. [I found this play particularly interesting because my uncle Jimmy Quirk, who was publisher and editor of Photoplay during its golden period, is one of the supporting characters] The fascinating story of this ill-fated Hollywood love affair is well-served by a fine cast of talented performers, including JoHary Ramos as Navarro and Shay Coleman as Jimmy Quirk. And I'll be very surprised if Stephen Smith, who plays Herbert Howe, and who exhibits that certain “star quality” in spades, isn't soon discovered by Hollywood. You can read all about Ramos, Coleman and Smith – not to mention the other talented cast members – on the Wings website. A full review of the play will be posted soon; for now I urge people to get tickets for a highly interesting real-life Hollywood variation – to put it mildly – on Brokeback Mountain. The play will be running until  January 21st 2006. Lawrence J. Quirk. NOTE: To read about Ramon Navarro's relationship with Rudolph Valentino visit our sister site Quirk's Reviews Online by clicking here: http://quirksreviews.tripod.com/id22.html

Alyson Cambridge with her father

LINDEMANN YOUNG ARTIST DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM CONCERT. Sunday, December 4th, 2005. At the Metropolitan Opera House, Lincoln Center, New York City. This program takes talented young singers and trains them in a one to three year program during which they perform exclusively at the Met in smaller roles, all the while being groomed to take on bigger challenges. This concert officially introduces these artists to the public. Mezzo Tamara Mumford and baritone David Won opened the program with a selection from L'italiana in Algeri while New York tenor Dimitri Pittas and bass Jordan Bisch followed with a piece from Mozart's Die Entfuhrung Aus Dem Serail. Pittas was particularly impressive in a piece from Donizetti's L'Elisir d'amore. Soprano Wendy Bryn Harmer, along with Jordan Bisch and tenor Russell Thomas, scored in a trio from Faust; Thomas was heard to strong advantage in another trio from Rigoletto with Bisch and Mumford. The other singers – all first-rate – included sopranos Lisette Oropesa, Jennifer Black and Joslin Romphf, who teamed with Mumford for a quartet from Peter Grimes; and mezzo Kate Lindsey, who joined Harmer and Oropesa for the famous trio from Der Rosenkavalier. Perhaps the star of the evening, however, was soprano Alyson Cambridge, who was heard in the act 3 quartet from La boheme [with Black, Thomas, and Won] and made quite an impression on the audience. There were eleven singers and nine numbers. Perhaps next year they should have eleven numbers and give each singer a solo? The concert was followed by a buffet and drinks on the Grand Tier of the Met attended by Met general manager Joseph Volpe and other luminaries. All in all, a fine evening at the wonderful Metropolitan Opera. Next time, however, the Met should have much better hors d'oeuvres, please. William Schoell.


THE AMERICAN CLOCK. Arthur Miller. HB Playwrights Foundation, Inc. Directed by Austin Pendleton. November 4th, 2005. Miller's play examines the dark years of the depression and its effect on various people and families, in an episodic style that sometimes resembles a film script. This approach makes the play a bit hit or miss, with strong, memorable scenes interspersed with others that don't work quite as well. It emerges as an odd, film-influenced play with musical numbers [at one point an attractive young lady comes out to sing a lovely rendition of For All We Know], a hodge podge of notions that serve to illuminate the period and its despair while at the same time distancing us from it to a certain degree. The play does get across much of the despair felt by the citizenry of the time, with its especially limited options for blacks in particular. Some of the younger actors are a bit overwrought at times, but there is nice work from Edward Boroevich, Michael Berry, Dave Rosenbaum, and many others. Among the older cast members Barbara Eda-Young and Kathleen Peirce, among others, certainly make an impression. The American Clock may not be one of Miller's masterpieces, but it is a worthwhile drama and this is a notable production of it. William Schoell


ZAZA. Ruggiero Leoncavallo. Presented by Teatro Grattacielo at Alice Tully Hall, Lincoln Center, NY. Saturday November 12, 2005. 8 PM.

Zaza may not be in the league of Leoncavallo's masterpiece Pagliacci, but it is a worthwhile, tuneful little verismo piece that can come alive with the right singers. The story concerns a performer who falls in love with a man who turns out to be married with a child, creating many tears and much wringing of hands. The music is particularly good in the latter half, with Leoncavallo skillfully bringing to life the torments and emotions of the characters. The main theme that opens the opera is a striking one. This one-evening performance presented by the Teatro Grattacielo was a showcase for soprano Aprile Millo, who did a nice if unspectacular job but had her fans – which seemed to consist of most of the audience – on their feet cheering. Stephen Gaertner as Cascart did a splendid job with his one special aria, and Gerard Powers also won applause as Milio. Eugenie Grunewald, Megan Monaghan, Jayoung Yoon, Daniel Lee, Mark Womack, Anthony Pulgram, Young-Bok Kim, Stephan Kirchgraber, Aida Baligh, Luis Emilio Cabrera, Kimiko Hata, and Angelica Asaro rounded out the cast. The Teatro Grattacielo Orchestra was well conducted by Alfredo Silipigni, who had a real feel for the material. The Teatro Grattacielo should be commended for their productions of often lesser-known verismo works that deserve a wider audience. While Zaza is hardly in the same class as Pietro Mascagni's magnificent Guglielmo Ratcliff, which the company has also done, it is easy to take and melodious enough to be quite engaging at times. A nice job. William Schoell.

photo: Robert Torres
Melissa Nearman in ROSARIES AND VODKA

ROSARIES AND VODKA. Written and Directed by Daniel Haben Clark. At La Mama March 24th – April 10th, 2005. 212-475-7710. www.lamama.org. Th – St 8 PM; Sn 2:30 PM and 8 PM.

A young Irish Catholic woman, Posey (Melissa Nearman), marries a charming, attractive – but alcoholic – man who is unable to provide for himself, let alone his wife and children. Although the church allows her to divorce the man, she isn't permitted to marry anyone else as long as he's alive. She becomes involved with a variety of men over the many years, most of whom want to marry her, but her answer is always the same. Posey's suitors include a soldier who is killed in the war, a much older Brazilian millionaire, and a flamboyant gigolo type who seems much more interested in getting to know her handsome grown son, Sonny (Brendan Burke) than Posey. Meant to be an indictment of the Catholic Church, the play can also be taken as a study of religious stupidity and masochism. [Some audience members may want to slap Posey across her face and tell her to get a life!] Constructed more along the lines of a screenplay than anything else, Rosaries and Vodka consists of many vignettes covering Posey's life, loves, family and friends. Rosaries and Vodka is undeniably entertaining, with many amusing lines and sequences, although there are times you wished it cut a bit more below the surface and developed a few more of its many, many characters (several cast members do double and triple duty) and sub-texts. There are comments on the probability that most priests are gay, and it is inferred that Sonny was molested as an altar boy [not that homosexuality and pedophilia should be confused] and that he is well-known among certain fashionable gay types such as Noel Coward and Tennessee Williams etc. etc. – but none of this interesting stuff is explored much more than that in the script. Still, the play does work pretty well as a character study – we see Posey learning to fend for herself and trying to become established as a businesswoman – and it gets points from this reviewer because it moves fast (despite all those scene changes!) and is never boring. I also love the final line, which I won't reveal here. I do think that a play indicting the Church could have used some scenes with a priest or two or maybe inside a church or with a church group– there's not much religion in Rosaries and Vodka, but perhaps we should be grateful for that.

photo: Robert Torres
Eugene Solfanelli plays Kent and other roles with aplomb

Rosaries and Vodka also offers a good cast some fine chances to show off its versatility. Jorge Rios nearly steals the show as a lecherous friend of Posey's family, not to mention a successful film director and the wealthy older man who tries to give her an engagement ring on his yacht. Eugene Solfanelli plays everything from Posey's father-with-a- brogue to the apparently AC/DC gigolo and does it all extremely well. Aliza Hedges adroitly plays Posey's daughter Lorraine as well as a sexy and bitchy movie star, among others. Marjorie Conn immediately rivets your attention in her highly professional turns as, respectively, Posey's mother, boss, and wallet-stealing client. Robin Long and Joe De Feo also do some very nice work, the former as Posey's frank-talking friend, Elaine, and the latter as Posey's husband and subsequent (chaste) lovers – a neat idea to have him play all of them (aside from the Brazilian). Michael Anthony Benvenutti makes a likable "stage manager" and others [he had to step into the roles literally overnight after the original actor twisted his ankle]. I believe the very attractive lead actress, Melissa Nearman, also stepped into the role on short notice (someone else is listed in the part on La Mama's web site); she is to be commended for doing as good a job as she does in such a long and difficult part that takes her from girlhood to old age. [The play jumps ahead many years after her ex-husband finally kicks the bucket, so we never learn why she didn't get remarried in those intervening years.] Just a quibble: Nearman has nice legs, yes, but girls didn't wear mini-skirts in 1933! REVIEW CONTINUES BELOW PHOTOS

photo: Robert Torres
Jorge Rios: charming scene-stealer
photo: Robert Torres
Robin Long scores as Elaine

Ultimately, whatever its flaws, Rosaries and Vodka is thought-provoking and enjoyable, a good, fun, interesting evening at the theater.  Now and then the playwright himself shows up to pontificate as one of the Popes, most of whom, he says, went straight to Hell! I may be biased in favor of this anti-Catholic play because I was born a Jew, raised a Protestant, and now am not religious at all (though let me assure everyone I have many loving Catholic friends, most of whom have lapsed – their religion, not their friendship). -- William Schoell

photo: Robert Torres
Author-Director Daniel Haben Clark as the Pope
photo: Robert Torres
babysitter (Aliza Hedges) and daddy (Joe De Feo) get into some bedroom action

More reviews to be posted soon.

Mailbox, Spinning

Please pardon our appearance as we revamp this web site. A change in format has created some lay out and photo problems which we will correct as soon as possible. Many thanks for your patience. -- The Editors

NOTE: press "home" on your keyboard to go straight back up to the top
Entire contents copyrighted 2004 - 2005 by William Schoell and Lawrence J. Quirk, except for items written by other authors, in which case said authors retain the copyright of their work . Opinions expressed by individual authors and reviewers are not necessarily the opinions of High and Low NY.